Seventy AS 0 ASPA objects, and the networks behind them

· Mingwei Zhang
rpki aspa measurement

ASPA deployment is usually tracked as a count, either of objects or of the ASNs that publish them. Cloudflare’s rpki.json for November 16 lists 4,139 objects from 4,136 ASNs, about 90 more than a week earlier, the kind of weekly figure the BGPKIT RPKI Deployment Tracker reports next to its ROA totals. Such a count is a reasonable trend line. What it cannot show is that one object authorizes two upstreams while the next attests that its network has none.

Seventy objects in that file, 1.7% of the total, take the second form: their provider set contains only AS 0, the value a network uses to declare that no AS supplies it with transit. They are worth a separate look, because what they do depends on where those networks sit in the AS graph, not on how many of them there are.

What an AS 0 provider set declares

The ASPA profile allows AS 0 only as the sole element of a provider set. The verification draft states what that means:

Registering an AS0 ASPA is a statement by the registering AS that it has no transit providers, and it is also not an RS-client at a non-transparent RS AS.

draft-ietf-sidrops-aspa-verification-29, Section 4

The object is a claim about position in the AS graph rather than about address space: the holder asserts that no AS supplies it with transit. Everything it protects follows from that claim. A network that is its own transit can make it honestly and at no cost. A network that buys transit and publishes the same object would contradict its own routing.

Who publishes one

Read by registered name, the seventy split into four groups; the full list is in the appendix so the classification can be checked.

GroupASNsShare of the cohort
Large transit and provider networks811.4%
Internet exchange and route-server ASNs3347.1%
Access ISPs and hosting1622.9%
Enterprises, institutions, test and unused ASNs1318.6%

Figure 1. The seventy AS 0 publishers by category. Categories come from registered ASN names; the full list is in the appendix.

Donut chart of 70 AS 0 objects by publisher category: 33 exchange or route-server, 16 access and hosting, 13 enterprise, test or unused, 8 large transit

The transit group is 8 ASNs from 7 organizations: Cogent (AS174 and AS16631), Arelion, GTT, Deutsche Telekom, Sparkle, Liberty Global, and AT&T.

The exchange group is the largest of the four: France-IX publishes 7 AS 0 objects, one per exchange or route server, NIX.CZ publishes 2, and 24 other exchange and route-server operators publish one each.

The access group is mostly group-level rollouts: Sunrise with 5 ASNs, Ziggo with 3, Telia Norge with 2, then Brightspeed, TeleData, ArubaCloud and others with one.

The last group is the long tail: two universities, a public DNS service, APNIC’s own services ASN, an oil and gas company, two CDN-named ASNs, a handful of small operators, two test ASNs, and ASNs that hold no ROA and originate nothing.

Where the object matters

An AS 0 object attests that the publisher has no providers. It is consulted hop by hop wherever the publisher appears in a path. The pairs it speaks to are the publisher and the AS one hop closer to the sender, and, under the downstream procedure, the publisher and the AS one hop closer to the origin; the provider-authorization function returns Not Provider+ for either, because the publisher has signed that no AS is its provider. A path that makes a provider-free network somebody’s customer is the shape a route leak or a forged path segment takes, and that is the case this object removes from the space of valid paths.

Whether a validator rejects such a path depends on the procedure it applies, and that depends on its relationship with the neighbor that sent the route, which an archive cannot see. The upstream procedure, used for routes from customers and peers, is Valid only if every hop is an attested customer-to-provider hop: a hop that is attested not to be one makes the path Invalid, while a hop with no object at all leaves it Unknown. The downstream procedure, used for routes from providers, lets the two ramps meet within one hop, which is where a legitimate peer-to-peer hop sits.

Reach therefore follows how often the ASN appears in paths, not how much it originates. Seventeen of the seventy appear in at least one path in the November 16 RIB.

Role in observed pathsASNsPath rowsDistinct prefixes
Large transit networks79.2M to 144M1.30M to 1.36M
Exchange and route-server ASNs7267 to 23,28323 to 11,020
Origin only36 to 1,7662 to 3
Not in any path5300

The transit row is where the object earns its keep. Each of the seven appears in paths covering 78% to 81% of the 1.67 million prefixes in the table, across 72 collectors, and six of the seven are mostly in the middle of a path rather than at either end: Cogent is mid-path in 116.9 million of its 119.9 million rows.

The seven exchange ASNs that appear are route servers that put their own number into the path. Transparent route servers never do, which is one reason 26 of the 33 in that group are absent here; their object matters only if someone puts the ASN into a path.

Three appear only as an origin, with two or three prefixes each: two are test instruments whose AS 0 objects make their own announcements evaluate as invalid, and one is a CDN ASN. For them the object acts at the origin hop.

The remaining 53 appear in no path in the table. Their objects are inert today and matter if the ASN is routed or forged into a path, which is why publishing one costs nothing. It is also why a count says little about value: the same object on Arelion and on a dormant ASN counts once each.

The mirror image

The same file shows the other side of the graph. Ranked by how many ASPA publishers name them as a provider, the top 15 ASNs are named by between 76 and 621 publishers each. Six of those 15 publish an ASPA of their own, including Cogent at 429 and Arelion at 258; the other nine, including Hurricane Electric at 621, Route64 at 258 and Lumen at 229, publish none.

Partial deployment is expected, and the procedure is designed around it: a pair with no attestation returns No Attestation, and the path is not rejected. The consequence is narrower than “ASPA does not work”: for a customer of one of those nine, the hop to its provider is attested and the hop above it is not.

Reproducing

curl --compressed -s -o rpki.json https://rpki.cloudflare.com/rpki.json
jq '.metadata.buildtime' rpki.json
jq '[.aspas[] | select(.providers==[0])] | length' rpki.json
jq '[.aspas[] | select(.providers==[0]) | .customer_asid] | sort' rpki.json

Provider rankings come from the same file: for every provider value in every object, count the distinct customer_asid values that name it. ASN names come from the RIR registry data and ROA counts from the RPKI objects themselves. The prefix counts in the second table come from one RIB snapshot of the public MRT archive for November 16, 2026, counting rows in which the ASN appears anywhere in the AS path.

Appendix: the 70 AS 0 publishers

Large transit and provider networks (8 ASNs)

ASNRegistered nameCCROAsAnnouncedPath rows
1299TWELVE99 Arelion Sweden ABSE2244154144,030,947
174COGENT-174 - Cogent Communications, LLCUS23164895119,859,462
3257GTT-BACKBONE GTT Communications Inc.US2240205453,334,296
6762SEABONE-NET TELECOM ITALIA SPARKLE S.p.A.IT46532751,377,853
3320DTAG Deutsche Telekom AGDE1660100113,311,847
6830LibertyGlobal Liberty Global Europe Holding B.NL253218712,125,538
7018ATT-INTERNET4 - AT&T Enterprises, LLCUS25446519,175,153
16631COGENT-16631 - Cogent Communications, LLCUS000

Internet exchange and route-server ASNs (33 ASNs)

ASNRegistered nameCCROAsAnnouncedPath rows
41441Speed-IX Serverius Holding B.V.NL0023,283
6777AMS-IX-RS Amsterdam Internet Exchange B.V.NL0011,945
55518SGIX-SG - Singapore Internet Exchange LimitedSG006,613
43100FRANCE-IX-LYN-RS France IX Services SASUFR422,943
51706FRANCE-IX-PAR-AS France IX Services SASUFR002,532
201376AUVERNIX-AS Association AuvernIXFR001,058
47200NIXCZ-RS NIX.CZ z.s.p.o.CZ00267
202010FRANCE-IX-MAPS-PAR France IX Services SASUFR5500
49624LUCIX LU-CIX Management G.I.E.LU2500
62848LIGHTBOARD-VERMONT-IXP - Lightboard RealtyUS200
201472STAMMT-IX STAMMT’IX AssociationFR200
215405FREEIX-GR Antonios A. CharitonGR200
32801INDYIX-MONITORING - Indianapolis Internet ExchUS100
212557FRANCE-IX-BOD-AS France IX Services SASUFR100
212674KA-NIX Karlsruhe Institute of TechnologyDE100
42064FRANCE-IX-MRS-AS France IX Services SASUFR000
44596COMMUNITYIX CommunityRack.org VereinCH000
46210YXEIX - Saskatoon Internet Exchange IncCA000
47184TOUIX-AS TOUIXFR000
47627NIXSK-RS NIX.CZ z.s.p.o.CZ000
53679MICEASN - Midwest Internet Cooperative ExchangUS000
57328DDIX-RS BCIX Management GmbHDE000
58171RIX-RS-AS Verein Rheintal IXLI000
59552SON-IX-Route-Servers Wobcom GmbHDE000
60247LABIX-AS LabitatDK000
62228FRANCE-IX-LIL-AS France IX Services SASUFR000
63145DFW-IX - Manchitas USA CorpUS000
197032TREX-RS TREX Regional Exchanges OyFI000
199036NLNOG-RING-AS Job SnijdersNL000
213874NSIX-Route-Servers Jakub KrsaCZ000
214786IPVS-IX SDNBUCKS BVNL000
218511Clue-IX-Routeserver-AS Netwerkvereniging ColocNL000
219524FRANCE-IX-PAR-B-IX France IX Services SASUFR000

Access ISPs and hosting (16 ASNs)

ASNRegistered nameCCROAsAnnouncedPath rows
8608QINIP Ziggo Services B.V.NL1200
11150LIGHTBOARD CORP - Lightboard RealtyUS200
21073ZORANET-AS Ziggo Services B.V.NL200
402598NUBIVANCE-01 - NubivanceUS100
5426SUNRISE-MOBILE Sunrise GmbHCH000
8231SUNRISE-AS8231 Sunrise GmbHCH000
9214SUNRISE-AS9214 Sunrise GmbHCH000
12799AS12799 Sunrise GmbHCH000
30903vtl-as-01 Ziggo Services B.V.NL000
35097CABLECOM Sunrise GmbHCH000
36633BSPD-MINT - BrightspeedUS000
39225FCIO-ALT Flying Circus Internet Operations GmbDE000
39525TELEDATA-METRO-AS TeleData GmbHDE000
47853STARNORDIC Telia Norge ASNO000
51135UPC-AS Telia Norge ASNO000
202242ARUBACLOUD-ASN Aruba S.p.A.IT000

Enterprises, institutions, test and unused ASNs (13 ASNs)

ASNRegistered nameCCROAsAnnouncedPath rows
400095CLOUDFLARENET - Cloudflare, Inc.US221,766
4492ASPA-INVALID Antonios A. CharitonGR221,612
59776LGI-CDN Liberty Global Europe Holding B.V.NL836
23506AS23506 - AV SERVICES LLCUS600
131211APNIC-SERVICES - Regional Internet RegistryAU300
138678GTDC-AS-AP - Grandbo Technology Development CoPH200
148110BGSBUR-IN - Baba Ghulam Shah Badhshah UniversiIN200
29529ANTONIS Antonios A. CharitonGR100
58899BHARAT-PUBLIC-DNS - BHARAT-PUBLIC-DNSIN100
12839KTR-TMP 2S Computers SRLIT000
134807SANTOS-AS-AP - Santos LimitedAU000
139749NANYANGTELECOMINC-AS-AP - Nanyang Telecom IncPH000
148009AUM-IN - Amity University, ManesarIN000

“Announced” is the number of prefixes the ASN originated in the RIB day 2026-11-15; “Path rows” counts rows of the 2026-11-16 RIB in which the ASN appears anywhere in the AS path.